Reviews

Based on 1430 reviews
94%
(1350)
4%
(53)
1%
(16)
0%
(4)
0%
(7)
I LOVE THIS STUFF

I use it on my face every morning and every night. My skin loves it.

Awesome! I'm so happy to hear that your skin loves it, thank you for sharing!

Black eye tint

This is the third eye tint I've bought (tried plum and cocoa- which I love). I really like the black for eye liner for special days but I cannot for the life of me get it to not smudge when I apply it as a mascara. I really love how it looks but it inevitably will smudge no matter what I try to do to mitigate that- any suggestions?

These jars are going to last a long time though, which is great.

Yeah, unfortunately smudges are more visible in the black color just because the pigment is so much darker - I'd suggest using a lighter touch than usual when you apply it as a mascara - but I'll experiment with it and see if I can come up with any other solutions! So glad you're enjoying these! Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

Great Oil

I find this oil very effective as the first step in a double cleanse.

I'm so glad to know that you're enjoying it! Thank you!

C
Cashmere Cardigan: limited edition fragrance
Customer
Spray not long lasting (for me)

I really wanted this to work as I don't ever use a fragrance but would love something natural to elevate my *vibe* however I found that the spray, which I chose for long wear time, faded within 1-2 hours. Wondering if body chemistry has any influence here? Or maybe it's the EOs in fragrance and something else will work? I am tempted to try either Amber or Tea layering spray...I went through this bottle (5 ml) so quickly that I likely will not repurchase. Apologize for the meh review and love the overall concept!

Many, many people aren't able to detect the volatile organic compounds that comprise completely natural fragrances on their own skin after an hour or two so there's no reason to apologize for an honest review! I always suggest trying samples to see how the scents wear on you before going for a bigger bottle. If an extended wear time is the top priority you'd probably be happier with a stronger all-natural scent like one of my other stand-alone fragrances, or, a different type of product that's made from a mix of synthetic and natural ingredients might feel like a better value for you. Best of luck with your search!

Perfect Monthly Gift for Myself

I love receiving the Off the Menu item each month. I use all of them and the subscription is a great deal for the products. Great way to try new items too.

Yay, I'm so glad you're enjoying the monthly treats! Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

I love it!

I love your products. I’ve used plant based oils on my skin for years due to sensitivity and realizing corporations don’t actually care about my skin but have struggled to figure out a good cleansing routine, aside from using soap every few days and sometimes making my own exfoliant. I recently made a tallow based butter (with shea butter and herb infused oil) that my skin loves but I needed a gentle cleanser and exfoliant to help clear buildup. Your cleansers are natural, and delicate enough for my face. After using the oatmeal cleanser nightly for about two weeks now and the exfoliant and pore refiner here and there, my skin feels calm, smooth and is glowing and I’m not having anymore acne breakouts. I also tried oil cleansing several times before your cleanser with a steamy wash cloth, which is initially how I found your website. I’m really enjoying it. Thank you for making simple products that are nourishing for my skin. Thank you for making great products!

Wow, this is so great to hear! I'm so happy to provide a cleanser that pairs well with your own handmade creations. Thanks so much for sharing such an awesome review!

Great scent!

I’m loving this room spray. I want to try them all! Thanks for coming up with the spray option. My house smells so fresh!

Yay, I'm so glad you like it! Thank you for sharing a review!

Delicate and a little earthy

It's a very warm rose, with a hint of cinnamon

I'm so glad to know that you're enjoying it! Thank you for sharing your thoughts!

J
Toner: skincare
Jessica M.
Holy Grail Product

This is the one product I've used for years without fail! It calms, cleans and makes my face feel really soft. I currently use the whole Twinkle skincare set and love it, but I've used the toner along with many other products in the past, and it always works. I have very sensitive skin and it never irritates and even calms my face if other products have caused irritation. Highly recommend!

Whoo hoo! I love hearing this! Cheers to many more years of great skin. :) Thank you for sharing your review!

Orange Blossom

I managed to grab the orange blossom scent while it was available, and I look forward to trying the next scent that comes out. This butter soaks in quickly and leaves my skin feeling soft and hydrated. I will definitely be buying more!

Lovely! I will be making more ASAP! Thanks so much for the review!

Stain

Don’t be scared by the word stain. It is AMAZING.. The color is lovely. Dare I say a rose glow of pleasure.

Yay, I'm so glad you love it! Thank you for the amazing review!

Limited edition plum

This was my first time using eye tint and I must say I'm very impressed. I purchased the limited edition plum and used it for the first time today. It lasted all day; through caring for two littles- meals, baths and bedtime. No smudging under eye and didn't budge as an eyeliner. I used filter balm, the eye tint, shimmer powder then finishing powder. I like this for everyday mom stuff when I don't need to have full-on lengthening, volumizing mascara but I still want something on my eyes. Very impressed and I will be ordering in other colors.

This is so great to hear! I'm so glad to know that you're happy with your first eye tint experience. Thank you for sharing such a nice review!

W
Cashmere Cardigan: limited edition fragrance
Wris S.
A scent to live in

This is such a cozy scent! I would love for all my sweaters to smell like this!

Yay, so happy to know you're enjoying it - thank you again!

W
Seasonal Shimmer Balm Bundle
Wris S.
Give me shimmer

I love these shimmer balms for creating the perfect glowy look for fall. I am using ginger snap on my eyes and as a highlighter, with sugar plum fairy on my cheeks and lips. I appreciate the buildable sheer color and beautiful shimmer!

I'm so glad to know you're enjoying these colors, thank you for sharing your review!

Luxury face oil

This oil is a luxurious treat for my skin. I use it after the facial cleanser and before the butter. It has a subtle floral and earthy scent that I love, and it leaves my face soft and glowing.

It does feel luxurious, doesn't it?! Thank you for the glowing review to match your glowing skin! :)

Reveal glowing skin!

I am loving this facial cleanser! It is gently exfoliating and leaves my skin feeling supple and clean! Of course I follow it up with the oil, butter, and/or filter balm. I am so happy to have found this magical line of skincare!

What a lovely review! I'm so glad you're enjoying everything, thank you so much!

Best skin care

I use the cleanser two-three times a week and the toner and oil every day! Best natural skin care ever!

Awesome, that makes me so happy to hear! Thank you!

Fantastic Cleanser

Love the cleanser. My skin feels great and looks great. It’s really helped clear up any underlying clogged pores. Will definitely continue to use and order.

YAY, I SO love to hear that you're looking and feeling great in your skin! Thank you for sharing this review!

Soft and creamy

I absolutely love the feel of this product and how it makes my skin feel after!

So glad you're enjoying it, thank you!

C
Cashmere Cardigan: limited edition fragrance
Caroline L.
Really nice

I’ve ever been a scent person, but on someone’s suggestion I tried Casmere Cardigan and I love it! It’s early, mysterious and perfect for fall. Thank you!

I'm so glad to hear this! Thank you for giving it a try and sharing your thoughts!

M
Cashmere Cardigan: limited edition fragrance
Melissa L.

Great cozy scent

So glad you like it! Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

Beauty butter!!

I love a new surprise every month that’s handmade with love! It’s so much fun trying new things! This month we got the beauty butter, which is great for dry skin for the winter. It smells soooo good and is so moisturizing! There were some left overs so I snatched two more!

Yay, you're going to be so well moisturized this winter! Thank you for sharing this review!

Favorite surprise every month!

Stefanie does such a great job at crafting unique fragrances that will have you obsessed. I’ve loved every scent I’ve tried that she’s created! I would definitely give this subscription a chance!

Thank you so much! It's so fun picking out what to make every month. I'm glad you enjoy everything too!

A True Delight to the Senses!

I absolutely LOVE this scent! It feels effortless, unique, woodsy but warm…if only my perfume bottles were bottomless! 😉

What a lovely description! I'm so glad you love it. Thanks for the review!

Absolutely wonder! Silky consistency and makes my hair and scalp feel clean and flake free! The scent is very clean and soft.

That's so great to hear! Thank you for sharing your thoughts!

Explore

Read

  • The Perfume Archives are Closing After January 31, 2025

    The Perfume Archives are Closing After January ...

    It's the end of an era, friends... This is your official notice that after January 2025, I'll be closing the Perfume Archives and saying goodbye (kind of!) to all of...

    The Perfume Archives are Closing After January ...

    It's the end of an era, friends... This is your official notice that after January 2025, I'll be closing the Perfume Archives and saying goodbye (kind of!) to all of...

  • January 2025 Surprise Scent Mood Board

    January 2025 Surprise Scent Mood Board

    Happy New Year!  It's already almost time to order January's Surprise Scent, so here's your mood board hint:   January's scent is an oldie but a goodie - a soft, refreshing,...

    January 2025 Surprise Scent Mood Board

    Happy New Year!  It's already almost time to order January's Surprise Scent, so here's your mood board hint:   January's scent is an oldie but a goodie - a soft, refreshing,...

  • December 2024 Surprise Scent Mood Board

    December 2024 Surprise Scent Mood Board

    Wow, another year of the Surprise Scent Monthly subscription is coming to an end - time really does fly when you're having fun! There's just a little over a week left...

    December 2024 Surprise Scent Mood Board

    Wow, another year of the Surprise Scent Monthly subscription is coming to an end - time really does fly when you're having fun! There's just a little over a week left...

1 of 3